lyrics might be good but mr. gilmour created the wonderful music to those lyrics. my votes for dave 
I voted for Dave, but I'm going to rank them too.
1. Dave
2. Rick
3. Syd
4. Nick
5. Roger
Can I pick Roger and Syd? :(
Rick Wright, baby! All the way!
Sorry about not putting Bob Klose in there!
Mine, in order:
David Gilmour
Nick Mason
Rick Wright
Roger Waters
Syd Barrett
Musically I admire Dave most. But Rick adds a lot and is sometimes underappreciated. Personality wise, I like Nick most.
Rog and Nick have the best sense of humour I feel; even If Roger's is dark.
Roger Waters, even though he's a dick.
The_Marching_Hammers Wrote:Roger Waters, even though he's a dick.
:laugh:
gotta choose from Rick & Dave.... hmm... yeh baby Dave...
Of course it's Gilmour... that's my boy right ther lol!!
Dave. Second would be Rick.
Anyone noticed how Gilmour is so much better writing Pink Floyd songs than David Gilmour songs?