cevor Wrote:MacPhisto Wrote:Aww, I'll bet I'm the one of the only ones here who thinks The Final Cut completely annihilates all post-Roger Floyd :(
TFC is a great Rog solo album. 
The Final Cut is a great Roger solo album - but
Amused to Death is even better.
Disagreed!
Sorry, had to.
Quote:Should have added that I like post-Waters Floyd a lot better than post-Floyd Waters as well.
I totally agree with you!
I am a David Gilmour Fan, I dont like post-Waters Floyd is this a Momentary Lapse of Reason?
I remember buying The Final Cut the day it came out..listened to the whole thing, thought hmmm, let's try again....and I was left with my first impression...as far as Pink Floyd went it was rubbish (the years have done little to change that opinion). Then, AMLOR was released, once again I bought it the day it was released, and to this day I still think it's a pretty good Pink Floyd album, not great, but pretty good. Just my opinion of course but Roger had simply forgotten that while music can, and very often does make a statement, it had still better be music, not just lyrics sung (spoken) on top of some melodies (which for the most part aren't even catchy ones).
I like it all. I think that it is great that they carried on after Roger left.
One could say he never left, but we all know he was very was surprised they carried on at all.
a Momentary Lapse of Reason is bad(by pink floyd standerds) division bell is great