Shine On parts 1-5 easily
Only "song" (too weak word for these masterpieces) to rival it would be Echoes... and only song to surpass it would be David's two live versions of it on RTN and Gdansk...
Come to think of it those live versions ruined the album version. I can't listen to it anymore
I can't pick one there all good.
Floydfan91 Wrote:I can't pick one there all good.
Alan's Psychedelic Breakfast and A Saucerful of Secrets aren't. In fact, they're terrible.
Sheep, no competition in my opinion. It's the only Floyd song over 9 minutes that doesn't have a part in it that sounds kinda worthless. It rawkz, too.
When i started listening Pink Floyd, it was Shine on you crazy diamond..
Now its Atom Heart Mother Suite
MacPhisto Wrote:It's the only Floyd song over 9 minutes that doesn't have a part in it that sounds kinda worthless.
Very good point. Although I do like parts of all the songs in that list, most do have parts that I feel could have been cut out. Consistency is probably the key to success with long songs such as these.
All of them
Hmm pigs 3do and echoes are about equal favorites of mine, but i have to go with pigs just for it being the under dog
Intended pun? ^
And Nick's Boogie, you can't seriously believe that, can you? Some of the tracks above are terribly bland.
Ok, so everyone who says all of them thinks Echoes is equal to Alan's Psychedelic Breakfast, and Shine on is equal to Saucer?
Let me guess... no!