Pink Floyd Online Forums

I would say no, just because its only truly great within the context of the album. Without hearing the rest of The Wall, it doesnt really make sense. Amazing song, though rocker

Mrsocko54 Wrote:I would say no, just because its only truly great within the context of the album. Without hearing the rest of The Wall, it doesnt really make sense. Amazing song, though

Haha, good point.

What album is this song on? I don't think I've heard it.

Marcellus Wrote:What album is this song on? I don't think I've heard it.

"The Wall", second to last on the album. ???

Edited By carefulwiththataxluke on 1111952948

Not my favorite song but very bold, daring, different, & cool. Great idea as well as way to sum up the entire album by bringing all the characters together in one place. <span style='font-size:12pt;line-height:100%'>Got to love it!</span> hammers

Intelligently written song, but I personally don't think it comes close to other Floyd greats, never mind top songs by other artists.

i love the song but ive listined to it soooooo many times im kinda bored of it :sleepy:

I love it. I describe Roger's voice as almost feminine. Like a baritone playing a soprano in a 9th grade choir. In this(and What Shail We Do Now) he trades that voice in for the sound of Chris Rock outta hell...

its my favorite song from the wall but deffinatly not my favorite song of all time

Yeah, not the best of all time. In fact I need to listen to The Wall again!

Mrsocko54

The_Madcap

Marcellus

carefulwiththataxluke

carefulwiththataxluke

Steve Hill

viewaskew

AndersonCouncill

onthewing12

PinkSchism