Pink Floyd Online Forums

Full Version: Led Zeppelin are a bunch of overrated c**ks. - That's right, I said it...
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.
Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
Led Zepplin has a certain mystery and aura to them that must be understood to be appreciated. If you don't get it (which I don't think even they did. The mystery was almost certainly unintentional), than I can see how it would come out pretty sleazy.
Nirvana may have been derivitave and over-celebrated for doing things in rock music that had been done years prior (fun fact: Kurt said that "Smells Like Teen Spirit" was his attempt at writing a Pixies song. He failed miserably, but that's beside the point). But Kurt's brilliant songwriting and truly underrated guitar playing (listen to Bleach and tell me he doesn't rock) make up for his lack of originality, plus he was pretty endearing. So those who say he sucks either don't get his music or are simply afraid to get his music because Nirvana have been so massively overrated by critics it's not even funny.

As for Led Zeppelin, I agree that they aren't the ultimate when it comes to classic rock or rock music in general. I'm not that great of a guitar player, but I can recognize that Jimmy Page was not as godly as people make him out to be. He's playing pentatonic and blues scales only sped up and with little intricacies like bends, pull offs/hammer ons, and oblique bends. Robert Plant was an average vocalist at best; and grating at worst. The only truely great musicians in the band were John Bonham and John Paul Jones.

My tuppence.
Scream1008 Wrote:Overrated songs: Whole Lotta Love, Immigrant Song, Black Dog, Trampled Underfoot.

Crappy songs: You Shook Me, Hats Off to (Roy) Harper, Four Sticks, The Crunge, Trampled Underfoot (never really liked it), Candy Store Rock, Carouselambra

Excellent songs: Pretty much everything else
I agree, You Shook Me, Hats Off to Roy Harper, and The Crunge really are pretty bad songs...especially The Crunge :sleepy:
hey, I like The Crunge, and Hats off! I really like Trampled Underfoot too. Meh to each his one, I suppose
Three Different Ones Wrote:hey, I like The Crunge, and Hats off! I really like Trampled Underfoot too. Meh to each his one, I suppose
I do think Trampled Underfoot is pretty cool.
The Crunge, Hats Off!.., & Trampled Under Foot are among some of my favorite Zeppelin tunes. You Shook Me is just pure blues-rock to me, I love it. Four Sticks is OK.
Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
Reference URL's