Pink Floyd Online Forums

Xardie Wrote:

roryguiry Wrote:I don't believe you can say one album is better than another, all his stuff is as good as the next. Your not a true waters fan if you think one's better than the other.

That's ridiculous claim. Artist can and should be criticized.

Ultimate and gross example: I like someones painting and can be considered fan of his work. He then goes off and paints my house with his own crap. Yes, with his own crap. So I much love that piece of art because I am (or after that was) fan of his?

I guess I've done this before but

3. Pros and Cons of Hitch Hiking

Worst album I own and one of worst ever recorded. Torment

2. Radio KAOS

mind numbingly unimpressive and boring record. Stupidest concept ever for which Rog deserves to be shot. Radio Waves is ok and Tide Is Turning is good. Rest is naff

1. Amused To Death

Absolute masterpiece and one of the best albums of all time

LOL, that's pretty harsh! Although I totally agree with you about being able to criticize artists.

I also agree that ATD is really head and shoulders over the other two albums, but I like a lot of the tunes on Radio KAOS, and Pros and Cons has great playing and some good singing from Roger... it's mostly the tunes, or lack of thereof, that turns me off from the album. Plus most of the lyrics don't really touch me in the way that many of Roger's lyrics do.

Ok so I admit I love all of Roger's material.
Anyway
Pros and Cons
Radio kaos
Amused to death
We get so many requests to play songs off of Radio Kaos...but alas its not Pink Floyd...

mabewa Wrote:[quote=Xardie]
[quote=roryguiry]
I don't believe you can say one album is better than another, all his stuff is as good as the next. Your not a true waters fan if you think one's better than the other.

I don't really understand how to use these commands so I'm just hoping my message comes through. I couldn't agree with the above comment more. I can't name my favorite Roger Waters album because they are all my favorites, but I can say I love all of them and listen to all of them equally.

Roger's solo career is boring.

There, that oughta shake things up a little.

Glukkonitis Wrote:Roger's solo career is boring.

There, that oughta shake things up a little.

so it is

minus ATD

No. Sorry.

i never had a chance to listen to his solo albums. are there any good songs or is it just because you're huuuuge fans? (i'm not being sarcastic).

I like them all,
but Amused to Death is my fav by a long shot.

I like Pros and Cons and Amused to Death much more than I like anything accomplished in Pink Floyd. Although Radio KAOS has a few good songs, I don't really like it that much.

The Pros and Cons of Hitchhiking is a masterpiece. There will probably never be a better album.