I first of all would like to to say this defintly a rockfilm and an artfilm and has so many trippy ahead of its time ideas carved out of the woodwork in this masterpiece. Both versons are killer and the songs put the studio versions to shame. Especially saucerful and Ax.

well my fav bits are the scenes shot behind the amps with the subliminal flash on echoes pt1 and the sauceful of secrets madness , amazing

Definetly when gilmour is belting out "celestial voices" (whatever the name of the last part) in Saucerful of Secrets. Shivers every time

btw, in my opionion i think this should be moved to the films section

I HATE the director's cut.

The original is excellent.

I love the whole film,it's a classic,and a great example of the earlyish Floyd,as there are not many concert films about,compared to say The Beatles,Gilmour is great throughout,and Rick plays some wonderful organ,Echoes and A Saucerful Of Secrets being standouts,but i also love the footage of the Dark Side Of The Moon sessions,it's a shame they did'nt put more footage on the D.V.D. as there is plenty of room for it.



Edited By qjamesfloyd on 1088431989

I love both versions as well, I especially like Set the Controls, and moved to films :)

Careful With That Axe, Eugene.

From the original film of course. The new version blows.

Does anyone remember when during Ax when roger is yelling and fire goes on his face like they killed him off or something anyway its beutiful.

And yes celeistal voices is defitly the best part of ASOS and the greatest peice of music the did period.

Lumiere Wrote:Careful With That Axe, Eugene.

From the original film of course. The new version blows.

?????
which new version???
I know only one version of this live..
and what's director's cut?

The directors cut is what the director of this Adrian maben did with the footage of them making darkside and several interveiws with Dave, Nick, rick and Roger. Also it has revamped or ruined the song segments. It's not that bad at all but it would have saved damage to keep the song segments to its self.