I thought it would be nice to revive this thread. I voted for Nick. :)

Definitely Nick. If you've read Inside Out, you'd get it. Also, drummers are always a little "off", which adds to their charm.

Nick Mason is a very funny guy if you haven't gotten it yet buy Inside Out. He is a funny laid back guy that goes with the flow and tries not to get in the drama of the rest of the band. Roger Waters is very funny if you listen to his interviews and music. He can be really funny.

Nick's hilarious. The whole "apple pie with no crust" thing in Pompeii is too funny. Funnier than the oyster bit.

they both were funny. I like them both. Nick is cute with the crustless pie. Roger can be a smart@$$ somtimes but he can be pretty funny.

Nick, definitely. He can also really write. Its a pity he never wrote any lyrics, it would have been a welcome change from all the doom and gloom.

He did write some lyrics, actually: The Merry X-Mas song (although it's unreleased). I think with his sense of humor and overall persona, while an incredibly funny and likable guy......he'd make a horrible songwriter. LOL

Roger Waters and Gerald Scarffes Comentary on The Wall DVD. "What are those flowers doing Gerald?"

yes Roger and Gerald were very funny during the Comentary like how Roger wanted to wear jeans in his early teens but he had to wear knickers and he said something about boys who had to wear knickers in theor early teens turn into Bleeding Heart Arists. It was kind of cute.

At the beginning of the film with the MGM Lion

Roger; "I remember this bit."
Gerald; "Yes I remember this bit."
Roger ; "With the big pussy cat."
Gerald; "Done in the London Zoo wasn't it?"
Roger; "Yeah."

Cracks me up every time.