ha, just heard it on Palladia channel 816 Time Warner cable. LOVE IT!!! Turned my kids onto it, well, I made them listen to it! The power of parenthood. Sweet David Gilmour. XOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOOX

pinklit Wrote:ha, just heard it on Palladia channel 816 Time Warner cable. LOVE IT!!! Turned my kids onto it, well, I made them listen to it! The power of parenthood. Sweet David Gilmour. XOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOOX

Okay, so, it's a long story, but, basically, I ended up with a copy of Gdansk yesterday. Here's my opinion on it...

It is, quite possibly, the most plain, dull and depressingly boring live album I have ever heard in my entire lifetime. Even more so than Pulse.

But that's just my opinion.

I find, that Remember That Night has far better versions of Echoes, Comfortably Numb, etc., but I still enjoy listening to Live in Gdansk.

MacPhisto Wrote:Okay, so, it's a long story, but, basically, I ended up with a copy of Gdansk yesterday. Here's my opinion on it...

It is, quite possibly, the most plain, dull and depressingly boring live album I have ever heard in my entire lifetime. Even more so than Pulse.

But that's just my opinion.

You, good sir, are completely insane.

But that's just my opinion. ;D

Addendum: "Echoes" in Gdansk is the greatest version of that song to me, and I've heard a *lot* of bootlegs of that particular tune. (Seriously, if they gave out doctorates on "Echoes", I'd be DrKalteraphine.)

very good album in my opinion

It's great i love it !!! Fantastic preformance

This is one of my all-time favorite albums, even amongst those artists who are not Pink Floyd and were never in Pink Floyd. I currently have the 2CD version, but I'd like to get the 2CD+DVD version, possibly for my birthday in a couple weeks. There really is no way to express how much I love his music, his voice, his guitar playing skills -- suffice to say, the English language ran out of superlatives to describe him a long time ago.

I hope those here who don't have it yet, go pick it up. It's not to be missed.

Highlights for me are Echoes (!), Fat Old Sun, Astronomy Domine, Shine On... and Dave's great great playing and singing! I think this might be the best live vocals I've ever heard from him. Esp Shine On!

Can't forget Comfortably Numb. That solo is *almost* as good as P*U*L*S*E. Almost.