Poll: What is the greatest Pink Floyd solo song ever?

Wings on the Pig · 11-11-2008 12:16 PM

Aren't you a fan of On An Island Eric? glare

Possibly Related

OlgaHH · 11-13-2008 08:46 AM

I love "There is no way out of here" from group of these songs. "Against the odds" and "Night..." are not my favourite songs of Richard. I don't like songs of Roger are in this list. Syd's songs... it's not my cup of tea though they are interesting. Others songs of David I don't like too.

What was criterion of the list to add THESE songs? Fact that they were singles, isn't it?

p.s.: I think that solo creation is worse than group creation (not always but often).

Xardie · 11-13-2008 09:52 AM

OlgaHH Wrote:I love "There is no way out of here" from group of these songs. "Against the odds" and "Night..." are not my favourite songs of Richard. I don't like songs of Roger are in this list. Syd's songs... it's not my cup of tea though they are interesting. Others songs of David I don't like too.

What was criterion of the list to add THESE songs? Fact that they were singles, isn't it?

p.s.: I think that solo creation is worse than group creation (not always but often).

*gasp*

You don't like Murder or On an Island??? (both by far superior to 95 % of Floyd work IMO)

Anyway, you wanna know how these songs were chosen?

By vote.

Everyone voted for best song on album. These tracks emergent as winners in their respective polls.

Wings on the Pig · 11-13-2008 10:19 AM

OlgaHH Wrote:I love "There is no way out of here" from group of these songs. "Against the odds" and "Night..." are not my favourite songs of Richard. I don't like songs of Roger are in this list. Syd's songs... it's not my cup of tea though they are interesting. Others songs of David I don't like too.

What was criterion of the list to add THESE songs? Fact that they were singles, isn't it?

p.s.: I think that solo creation is worse than group creation (not always but often).

What are you talking about? Hardly any of those songs were released as singles!

And they were all voted in by the members of this board from way before you joined. Next time, please can you ask politely . . .

silverpot · 11-13-2008 12:18 PM

Wings on the Pig · 11-13-2008 01:07 PM

I'm sorry. Sad

I was a bit annoyed earliar . . .

OlgaHH · 11-14-2008 05:44 AM

Wings on the Pig, you don't have to feel guilt for yourself.) I just asked how these songs had been included in this voting, and that's all.

Wings on the Pig · 11-14-2008 09:05 AM

OlgaHH Wrote:Wings on the Pig, you don't have to feel guilt for yourself.) I just asked how these songs had been included in this voting, and that's all.

Thank you for being so very forgiving. Happy

OlgaHH · 11-15-2008 05:27 AM

Not at all.)

~~Three Different Ones~~ · 11-15-2008 11:33 AM

Wings on the Pig Wrote:Aren't you a fan of On An Island Eric?

I heard it once..I don't remember it at all..and idk I'm not like exactly jumping and going out of my way to get any most post-floyd david..I may sometime if i'm really bored and have nothing to listen to

Poll: What is the greatest Pink Floyd solo song ever?
	There's No Way Out of Here - David Gilmour
	Murder - David Gilmour
	On An Island - David Gilmour
	Night of a Thousand Furry Toys - Rick Wright
	Against the Odds - Rick Wright
	Watching TV - Roger Waters
	Radio Waves - Roger Waters
	Dominoes - Syd Barrett
	Dark Globe - Syd Barrett
	The Pros and Cons of Hitchhiking, Part 10 - Roger Waters

Possibly Related Threads...
Thread:		Author	Replies:	Views:	Last Post
	C Numb - heard version with - 'Fleeting Glimpse' AFTER the Final Solo?	BSloan1960	5	365	03-31-2010 10:49 AM Last Post: quicksilver
	C Numb - version with - 'Fleeting Glimpse' AFTER the Final Solo?	BSloan1960	0	146	03-28-2010 09:14 AM Last Post: BSloan1960
	Best slide guitar solo - Which song has the best slide guitar?	sjmcd	24	1,786	11-03-2009 07:27 PM Last Post: Lady Floydian
	Best Album - Grand Final, Round 14, Album Cover Art	Wings on the Pig	14	2,795	04-06-2007 05:26 AM Last Post: Wings on the Pig
	Solo Song vs. Solo Song - like other topic	IbanezIsTheColour	92	4,134	12-21-2006 01:18 PM Last Post: Three Different Ones

Threaded Mode \| Linear Mode Best Solo Song - Grand Final
Author	Message