Am I The Only One who doesen't like Post-Waters Floyd?
#11
Well, post-Waters PF is not so good, but I like it much more than The Final Cut. However, most of all I like pre-DSOTM Pink Floyd!
Reply
#12
Should have added that I like post-Waters Floyd a lot better than post-Floyd Waters as well.
Reply
#13
silverpot Wrote:Should have added that I like post-Waters Floyd a lot better than post-Floyd Waters as well.
Blasphemy!!!!!

Actually...I like both equally well but I think if they were still combined we'd get some really good music instead of good music.
Reply
#14
mikoyan29 Wrote:
silverpot Wrote:Should have added that I like post-Waters Floyd a lot better than post-Floyd Waters as well.
Blasphemy!!!!!

Actually...I like both equally well but I think if they were still combined we'd get some really good music instead of good music.

Absolutely. IĀ´m with you there.
But alas, that was not possible, David and Roger had grown too much apart.
David was fed up with all the words and concepts and Roger didnĀ´t care enough for the musical side of it. Instead we got those things separately.

But personally, I listen to music because of the music. Not because of the lyrics and concepts.
Hence my preferences.
Reply
#15
Pink Flow Wrote:I actually prefer it to the Wall and the Final Cut.

To The Final Cut, yes!
Reply
#16
I do like post-Waters Floyd, AMLOR has a few good songs and TDB has more, but there are plenty of people here/used to be here who definitely don't like it...Whistling
Reply
#17
I do like post waters Floyd. I can pretty much listen to anything from Meddle onwards. I think AMLOR and TDB have their bright spots and a couple weak spots. Yes, it does sound new age-y, but I still like it. For some reason, I really like the song Keep Talking.
Reply
#18
Mr. Mojo Risin Wrote:
Pink Flow Wrote:I actually prefer it to the Wall and the Final Cut.

To The Final Cut, yes!

yep
Reply
#19
Aww, I'll bet I'm the one of the only ones here who thinks The Final Cut completely annihilates all post-Roger Floyd :(
Reply
#20
MacPhisto Wrote:Aww, I'll bet I'm the one of the only ones here who thinks The Final Cut completely annihilates all post-Roger Floyd :(

TFC is a great Rog solo album. Laughing
Reply


Possibly Related Threads...
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  New Floyd/Waters Scans From Classic Rock pinkfloydfan1 34 5,545 08-26-2014, 08:30 AM
Last Post: sunshaderain7
  Post a Funny Floyd Picture Thread Pig (The Third One) 294 36,435 07-07-2011, 07:05 PM
Last Post: blue_ember
Cool First Post : Pink Floyd Tattoo jdub777 3 4,389 07-29-2010, 11:25 PM
Last Post: ~Gilmour Girl~
  Is Pink Floyd better without Roger Waters? A Saucerful of Secrets 51 7,366 11-29-2009, 06:35 PM
Last Post: Lady Floydian
  pink floyd on the radio - read my post b4 voting! The Painter Piper and Prisoner 33 5,151 06-06-2007, 07:49 AM
Last Post: Wings on the Pig



Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)