Outerspace Wrote:Why does Roger want Israelis to die?

Ridiculous!

cevor Wrote:

Outerspace Wrote:Why does Roger want Israelis to die?

Ridiculous!

Why? Israeli death due to suicide bombing has plummeted since the wall went up, who would want to change that?

BTW, does it occur to anyone that the Palis would never let a western rock and roller play a concert in their territory?

Implying that Roger wants Israelis to die is ridiculous. Taking a position that supports a free Palestinian state isn't nearly that radical.

If you support Roger Water's cause, join our group in facebook: Tear Down The Israeli West Bank Wall

cevor Wrote:Implying that Roger wants Israelis to die is ridiculous. Taking a position that supports a free Palestinian state isn't nearly that radical.

The Palestinians don't even want a free state. They want to live under Sharia law where women are property and gay people are put to death.

The Wall has been proven to save lives. Why not do something as useful as crusading to overturn seat belt laws.

Outerspace Wrote:

cevor Wrote:Implying that Roger wants Israelis to die is ridiculous. Taking a position that supports a free Palestinian state isn't nearly that radical.

The Palestinians don't even want a free state. They want to live under Sharia law where women are property and gay people are put to death.

The Wall has been proven to save lives. Why not do something as useful as crusading to overturn seat belt laws.

Therein lies the problem. It isn't up to the Israelis to decide what The Palestinians do with their free state. Like the Palestinians are a real threat to the 51st state. I suppose settlements save lives too.

The Palestinians don't even want their own state, if they did they would have had it decades ago. If the Palistinians were to achieve statehood the UN money would dry up and they would starve to death. They have to live like terrorists to survive.

BTW it isn't up to Roger Waters how Israel defends herself. Opposing a benign and effective life saver like that wall is baffling.

It would be much better for all support to be pulled from both entities and let them sort it out for themselves by throwing rocks at each other. Simple solution. It's always easy for the oppressor to make the rules, suppose no one came to the aid of the Israelis in the 40's.
Memory runs so short in the desert.

Only one side is throwing rocks. The other one is very well armed.

I could care less about Palis and Israelis, damnit. I just want to see Roger in concert here at some nice venue in the states where beer is overpriced, but the acoustics are superior and I can scream like a mad groupie all I want and not feel ashamed at all. You know?

Seriously though, the wall prevents Palis from getting the support they need from Israel. Roger is not wanting Israelis to die, he wants peace and since the Israelis are far better armed than the Palis, the ball is really in their court. All the Palis can do is fight as hard as possible because they face annihilation. Sure the Israelis would never do that, they only defend themselves well, but shouldn't they be the ones to lend a helping hand with all their resources? WWAD(What Would America Do?) Lol...

Bottom Line: The wall is counter-productive to establishing peace in the region and peace is what Roger is trying to influence.