(12-06-2009 02:50 PM)MaccaFan Wrote:  

(12-05-2009 11:15 PM)Electrophile Wrote:  

(12-03-2009 03:46 PM)MaccaFan Wrote:  He wouldn't because he's an atheist. At least Dylan's Jewish.

Christmas songs aren't always religious. Some of the best Christmas songs out there are secular. So it's very possible he could do one, or cover a secular song. His religious affiliation has nothing to do with that aspect of it.

Maybe, but he's infamously anti-Christian; I would be extremely surprised if he did a Christmas album, because, even with secular songs like "Jingle Bells" and "Run Rudolph Run", it's still affilitated with Christianity. But you never can tell.

I think he's more of an agnostic then an atheist. He also seems to be more anti-organized religion then anti-God.

I knew that David is an atheist, but didn't know that about Rog.

(01-01-2010 01:43 PM)azimuth Wrote:  I knew that David is an atheist, but didn't know that about Rog.

Well, a Christian would probably not do anything like "What God Wants," and he's said some things like "I don't believe in life after death," which is a Christian teaching.

Oh, well.

I think Pink Floyd did a Christmas song, Nick Mason was on the vocals I believe, and from all the giggling I'd say there was some eggnog involved.

Roger Waters at Christmas....

Careful With Those Christmas Lights, Dad
Shop Like Hell
A Saucerful of Cookies (for Santa, not you, so clear off)
The Bravery of Shopping Online

maybe he could do something like John Lennon did but I don't think of Roger Waters singing a Christmas song at all.

As hell has not frozen over as yet, he won't.

he wouldn't even then either.

Roger doesn't strike me as the "warm and fuzzies" type, and most Christmas songs are designed in a way, to give you that feeling. So just based on his personality, demeanor and overall attitude about life.....I can't see him doing. His religious or rather non-religious beliefs really don't factor in it for me.

not everyone is cut out to write a Christmas song or album. I don't see Roger Waters doing that.