Hmm, you're actually quite right about quite some things there. Despite the fact that I totally love Roger's music more than David's, I hate what he did "behind the scenes". At least he grew up and realized what he did wrong, though growing up at 60 might be a few years late. :)

I still think it's peculiar how people can love the same band, though be each other's counterparts when it comes to which albums they like... While you hate The Final Cut and love the post-Waters albums, my favorite album is The Final Cut, and the post-Waters albums are the ones I never listen to. :P But I suppose that's what you get when a band has made such versatile music through the many years!