(06-19-2010 11:39 AM)Electrophile Wrote:  Eh, no thanks. The Final Cut is the one album they never should have made. If Roger was that hell-bent on doing his own thing, to the exclusion of everyone else, he should have left the band in 1981 after The Wall shows were over.

That's when he really left isn't it? IMO yes it was.

The following debate here is quite interesting. I find it curious how things always circulate back to the same thing. It's the main reason we discourage direct comparison discussions like the classic David v Roger stuff. Each person's opinion is a valid as any other no matter how well schooled you perceive yourself. Quite frankly my thoughts on the whole thing would seem trollish, so I keep them to myself. Perhaps the "think thrice, type once" concept would work well here or just a splash of humility, it's a forum for god sakes.