I think it's an outstanding album that deserves its praise, but I find it odd how you dislike Welcome to the Machine, I've always loved it. Have a Cigar is significantly the weakest of the bunch.

shine on 1-5 11/10
welcome to the machine 10/10
have a cigar 10/10
wish you were here 20/10
shine on 6-9 9/10

Whoops. Sorry if my constant bitching about LOLOLOLOL I DON'T LIEK PNIK FLYOD AS MUCH AS I DID A YEAR AND A HALF AGO ROFLMFAO was annoying ya guise (evidently, it is), I suppose that's just me being even more of a dickhead than I normally am. In retrospect, it is kinda f*cking dickheady of me, so I think I'd be best off leaving 'em alone now. Sorry :(

Xardie Wrote:meh, this whole "lol I diss Floyd"-fad is already old and boring... Seriously. I haven't listened to Floyd for ages nor do they excite me as much nowadays but that doesn't in anyway lessen their brilliance.

Any song gets old when you play it thousand times

MacPhisto Wrote:WYWH - 2.5/5 (y halo thar eagles country ballad)


...=\

wow.... combined with your ludicruous claim that SOYCD (and Echoes and Pigs and Dogs) contains useless, axeable sections this post made sure I no longer have to give any consideration for your Floyd dissing

=/ indeed...


Shine On You Crazy Diamond, Pts. 1-5: 5/5
Welcome to the Machine: 5/5
Have a Cigar: 5/5
Wish You Were Here: 5/5
Shine On You Crazy Diamond, Pts. 6-9: 5/5

WYWH of course is my all time favourite album and has been since I first heard it

I honestly agree with you on everything...except Welcome to the Machine. Sorry, but there has to be a weak point on an album.

That gets a 4.5 out of me

I don't get how people see WttM as album's weak point and not Have A Cigar. Can somebody explain?

nope

No. I don't see how it's considered overrated

Of all the albums I've read/heard are overrated, WYWH never comes up. Even though I disagree with it, I can see where someone would say that DSOTM is overrated......but Wish You Were Here? I don't understand that. I'm curious what about this particular album makes it overrated to someone.

Wish You Were Here is not overrated at all, it's awesome at the least

shine on 1-5--10/10 rick's organ work is nothing short of frikkin epic

welcome to the machine 8/10 i have a strange feeling when i'm listening to this song, a good strange feeling.

Wish You Were Here 11/10 a song with much hope but also with much sorrow, a great combination

shine on 6-9 10/10 a great ending to an amazing album

on of my favorite albums, it's not overrated