Threaded Mode | Linear Mode

Wings on the Pig · 04-05-2006 03:00 AM

Although the Pink Floyd compilation album 'Echoes' is great to listen to, what songs would you have put in there if you had the choice of 26 songs, and in what order?

Edited By pinkfloydmadchris on 1144234883

Possibly Related

**Kimbers Sheep** · 04-05-2006 07:09 AM

moved to Albums

~~sjmcd~~ · 04-06-2006 03:17 AM

Disc 1

1. Speak To Me
2. Breathe
3. On The Run
4. Time
5. The Great Gig In The Sky
6. Wish You Were Here
7. Dogs
8. Comfortably Numb
9. Money
10. Us And Them
11. Any Colour You Like
12. Brain Damage
13. Eclipse

Disc 2

1. One Of These Days
2. Shine On You Crazy Diamond (I-V)
3. Astronomy Domine
4. Interstellar Overdrive (London 1966-1967 version)
5. Let There Be More Light
6. A Saucerful Of Secrets
7. Several Species Of Small Furry Animals Gathered Together In A Cave And Grooving With A Pict
8. The Narrow Way part 3
9. Atom Heart Mother Suite
10. Alan's Psychedelic Breakfast
11. Poles Apart
12. Echoes
13. Shine On You Crazy Diamond (VI-IX)

The restriction on 26 songs makes it hard - by the time I got to the end I only had room to include one song from after Roger left. Still, I like their early music better, so I don't really mind that much.

Edited By sjmcd on 1144322270

Let There Be More Floyd · 04-07-2006 02:52 PM

I remember doing something like this when I first joined, but I don't mind having another go nearly a year later.

1. Pigs on the Wing 1
2. Astronomy Domine
3. Let There Be More Light
4. Careful With That Axe, Eugene (Pompeii version)
5. Run Like Hell
6. Sheep
7. Echoes
8. A Saucerful of Secrets (maybe Pompeii version)
9. Breathe (in the Air)
10. Time
11. Wish You Were Here
12. Sorrow
13. Eclipse

disc 2
1. Shine On You Crazy Diamond I-IX
2. Us and Them
3. Dogs
4. Hey You
5. Fearless
6. Absolutely Curtains
7. Cirrus Minor
8. Money
9. One of These Days
10. Comfortably Numb
11. Jugband Blues
12. Childhood's End
13. Pigs on the Wing 2

There's no way those would fit on two discs, but I love the layout too much to change it...

wall1985 · 04-07-2006 04:36 PM

disc 1

1 the tide is turning (live at berlin 1990)
2 the tide is turning (live at berlin 1990)
3 the tide is turning (live at berlin 1990)
4 the tide is turning (live at berlin 1990)
5 the tide is turning (live at berlin 1990)
6 the tide is turning (live at berlin 1990)
7 the tide is turning (live at berlin 1990)
8 the tide is turning (live at berlin 1990)
9 the tide is turning (live at berlin 1990)
10 the tide is turning (live at berlin 1990)
11 the tide is turning (live at berlin 1990)
12 the tide is turning (live at berlin 1990)
13 the tide is turning (live at berlin 1990)

and for disc 2 i'd have...

1 the tide is turning (live at berlin 1990)
2 the tide is turning (live at berlin 1990)
3 the tide is turning (live at berlin 1990)
4 the tide is turning (live at berlin 1990)
5 the tide is turning (live at berlin 1990)
6 the tide is turning (live at berlin 1990)
7 the tide is turning (live at berlin 1990)
8 the tide is turning (live at berlin 1990)
9 the tide is turning (live at berlin 1990)
10 the tide is turning (live at berlin 1990)
11 the tide is turning (live at berlin 1990)
12 the tide is turning (live at berlin 1990)
13 the tide is turning (live at berlin 1990)

because the version off radio kaos isn't as good.

Third-Eye · 04-07-2006 04:49 PM

here i go......
1.Signs of life
2.Shine on you crazy diamond prts 1-5 and 7
3.Hey you
4.Interstellar overdrive
5.See Emily Play
6.ABTW part 1/The Hapiest days of our lives/ABTWprt 2
7.Money
8.Dogs
9.Pigs
10.Mother
11.Narrow ways part 3
12.ABTW prt 3
13.Goodbye cruel world

1.Echoes
2.One of these days
3.Sheep
4.Breathe
5.Time/Breathe reprise
6.Welcome to the machine
7.Have a cigar
8.run like hell
9.pigs prts 1 & 2
10.Jugband blues
11.Sorrow
12.Comfortably Numb
13.High Hopes

i doubt it would fit on cd

~~Three Different Ones~~ · 04-07-2006 05:45 PM

26 songs, eh? I think Echoes (the compiliation) was a huge failure, so I'm going to try and fit it down to two discs and fail

Disc 1: 1967-1970 (I can't think of a creative name, sue me)
1. Astronomy Domine
2. Lucifer Sam
3. Flaming
4. Interstellar Overdrive
5. The Gnome
6. Bike
7. Let There Be More Light
8. Corporal Clegg
9. Set the Controls for the Heart of the Sun
10. Careful with that Axe, Eugene (Live Ummagumma)
11. Cymbaline
12. The Nile Song
13. Summer '68
14. Jugband Blues

Disc 2: 1970-1973

1. One of These Days
2. If
3. Seamus
4. Stay
5. Free Four
6. Wot's..Uh The Deal?
7. Fat Old Sun
8. Breathe
9. On the Run
10. Time
11. Echoes

Disc 3: 1975-1979

1. Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Parts I-IX)
2. Have a Cigar
3. Wish You Were Here
4. Dogs
5. Pigs (Three Different Ones)
6. Mother
7. Young Lust
8. One Of My Turns
9. Don't Leave Me Now
10. Hey You
11. Comfortably Numb

Disc 4: 1979-1994

1. The Post-War Dream
2. Your Possible Pasts
3. Nobody Home
4. When the Tigers Broke Free
5. The Fletcher Memorial Home
6. Southhampton Dock
7. The Final Cut
8. Not Now John
9. What Do You want From Me?
10. High Hopes

Total Time: Way longer than the restrictions
Total Tracks: 46

Edited By Three Different Ones on 1144461331

Possibly Related Threads...
Thread:		Author	Replies:	Views:	Last Post
	Echoes (the song) 2 Disc Compilation of versions	brisk	0	136	03-23-2013 05:35 PM Last Post: brisk
	ooo a perfect Pink Floyd christmas gift!	Halfsteel	3	496	08-12-2010 11:54 PM Last Post: nikjem
	The "Commercial" compilation thread	Arno Sluismans	25	943	07-09-2010 08:59 PM Last Post: shockwave6668
	Pink Floyd compilation: Part 1, Round 1 - Let's make the ultimate Floyd album	sjmcd	28	3,314	11-07-2009 11:58 AM Last Post: codayo61
	Early "Best Of" compilation	Dyolf	9	487	10-04-2009 09:57 AM Last Post: Floyd 24/7

Threaded Mode \| Linear Mode Perfect Compilation Album - What do you want?
Author	Message