Threaded Mode | Linear Mode

~~sjmcd~~ · 12-23-2006 05:58 AM

IbanezIsTheColour Wrote:also, just think CN at Live 8 might be the last song they'll ever play together. :(

I can think of at least 10 songs I'd rather were the last they played than CN.

Edited By sjmcd on 1166882336

Possibly Related

Sir Frankie Crisp · 12-23-2006 02:38 PM

I like all 2 version I have; PULSE and studio.

Besides, the last time PF reunited was when Nick played with Dave and Rick at the RAH...did that happen or was that a rumour?

pinkfloydfan1 · 12-23-2006 06:18 PM

Sir Frankie Crisp Wrote:I like all 2 version I have; PULSE and studio.

Besides, the last time PF reunited was when Nick played with Dave and Rick at the RAH...did that happen or was that a rumour?

ye that was true

however my faviourite version is from the hammersmith odeon daves solo tour in 1984 and not to mention murder on that topur the solo is amazing

however i have a boot from the devision bell tour im not sure what date that is better than the final pulse version

Funky Dung · 12-23-2006 07:28 PM

Either the studio or PULSE version are my favorite. Undecided.

Quincy · 12-25-2006 08:27 AM

1. Live 8
2. Studio
3. PULSE

if it wasn't for the weak attempt to replace Waters on the PULSE version, it would probably be #2.

~~Three Different Ones~~ · 12-25-2006 11:32 AM

That's what I hate about the PULSE version is the guy who sings Roger's part (I can't be bothered to give a sh*t what his name is) can't sing very well, and that throws off the whole thing, making PULSE my least favourite

Ezekiel · 12-25-2006 02:20 PM

I love the version from The Wall Live. It's also orgasmic to hear CN on The Wall movie, watching Pink in the chair and all those people talking around him under the intro and the second verse. And watch Pink being dragged out of the hotel during the final solo.
Delicous.

~~sjmcd~~ · 12-26-2006 06:04 AM

Three Different Ones Wrote:That's what I hate about the PULSE version is the guy who sings Roger's part (I can't be bothered to give a sh*t what his name is) can't sing very well, and that throws off the whole thing, making PULSE my least favourite

I do believe his name is Rick Wright.

And my least favourite would have to be Live 8, due to the horrible screechy backing vocal.

Edited By sjmcd on 1167142385

Quincy · 12-26-2006 07:01 AM

No, I think Rick is overpowered by Jon Carin and that annoying bass player, whose name I have already forgotten.

When Rick sang Roger's parts on Dave's tour this year, it sounded AMAZING!

~~sjmcd~~ · 12-26-2006 07:04 AM

Quincy Wrote:No, I think Rick is overpowered by Jon Carin and that annoying bass player, whose name I have already forgotten.

When Rick sang Roger's parts on Dave's tour this year, it sounded AMAZING!

I read somewhere it was Rick, but upon listening to it again, it does seem as though several people are singing. The "annoying bass player" would be Guy Pratt.

Possibly Related Threads...
Thread:		Author	Replies:	Views:	Last Post
	the wall rare cx version	tdb246	1	857	11-17-2012 08:39 AM Last Post: Toptip
	Wish You Were Here - which version?	BrianL	0	238	08-19-2012 06:39 PM Last Post: BrianL
	ORIGINAL version of Dark Side Of The Moon	A Saucerful of Secrets	1	436	12-24-2011 12:37 PM Last Post: Lady Floydian
	Favorite version of Echoes?	PuttinOnTheRitz	18	951	12-24-2011 02:46 AM Last Post: A Saucerful of Secrets
	Studio version of The Travel Sequence, previously unreleased	Lady Floydian	6	489	11-19-2011 09:13 AM Last Post: Rykeys

Threaded Mode \| Linear Mode Best Comfortably Numb Version - best version
Author	Message