Threaded Mode | Linear Mode

InTheFlesh · 09-02-2003 07:17 PM

I got a rollng stones magazine today with the 100 saposidly greatest guitarist of all time. I opened it up to see some David Gilmour right on the last pageat 82. trailing behind Joan Jett. Who the hell put up this list. Eddy Van Halen is behind Kurt Kobain. What the hell he is number 12 on the list. Brian May is number 39 losing behind the guy from white stripes? Hes at 17. Beating carlos santana by 2. Who ever made this list can suck it. I just know there is gonig to be so many people complaining about this list.

Possibly Related

doctor_how · 09-03-2003 06:23 PM

Any list created by Rolling Stones or VH1 I don't really take into consideration that much. Music is such a subjective thing that you can't make a comprehensive list for it. I don't see why they bother. Makes good discussion material, though.

~SStork~ · 09-03-2003 07:38 PM

The only thing they did right was put Jimi Hendrix at #1 :blues:

Bar · 09-04-2003 12:13 PM

Outrageous. We had a big rant about this on another board. 82? They have no clue what they're talking about.

Caravanserai · 09-05-2003 08:31 AM

It's bullshit. They don't really care about music. They just drew lots after placing Jimi on number one, which is the only thing they did right.

simps · 09-05-2003 10:47 AM

When it was launched, Rolling Stone was respected as the highest authority in music journalism. A beacon of light in a dark field. I don't follow it regularly - being in UK I get Mojo, the UK equivalent, on subscription - but the reports about the poll suggest it has finally lost its great respectability and sold out. What say yee who are more in touch with the magazine?

bak2life · 12-27-2003 01:58 PM

That's stupid! How could he be so far at 82?

forksinatoaster · 12-28-2003 04:22 PM

What about the guitarists they neglected to even have *cough* vai and satriani perhaps... also this is based on memory i'm not sure if malmsteen was on it.. if he was i remember he was really high on the list.

shaun · 12-29-2003 03:57 PM

gilmour should be #3 or #2, but definitly not 82 :Oo:

wowser · 12-30-2003 02:45 PM

simps Wrote:When it was launched, Rolling Stone was respected as the highest authority in music journalism. A beacon of light in a dark field. I don't follow it regularly - being in UK I get Mojo, the UK equivalent, on subscription - but the reports about the poll suggest it has finally lost its great respectability and sold out. What say yee who are more in touch with the magazine?

mojo is NOt the equivelent of Rolling Stone - Rolling Stone is much more mainstream and less stuck in the past

Possibly Related Threads...
Thread:		Author	Replies:	Views:	Last Post
	Guitarist And Bass Discussion - Technical And General Talk Here	pinkfloydfan1	116	19,745	12-27-2011 01:18 PM Last Post: Rykeys
	Beginner guitarist? or want to learn play some Pink Floyd material?	ajabbar01	2	1,021	11-04-2008 03:32 AM Last Post: ajabbar01
	Who is your Favorite Guitarist	linhead	93	4,860	04-29-2005 02:55 PM Last Post: S.H.E.E.P
	The best guitarist - The best it?�s...	campe in the flesh	3	267	12-04-2004 11:48 PM Last Post: Kimbers Sheep

Threaded Mode \| Linear Mode Rolling stones 100 great guitarist - This is an out rage
Author	Message