Jintzey Wrote:Yeah can't say I was too impressed myself, but what do you expect from tribute albums? The only one I have found who does like it is someone who doesn't like PF.

Well, I expect a lot from a tribute album, especially the one I produced. Some are, in whole or in part, pretty damn good (like Signs of Life from Angular Records, An Allstar Lineup Performing the Songs of Pink Floyd, Luther Wright & The Wrongs, Rebuild the Wall, Dub Side of the Moon, Us & Them Symphonic Floyd, Echoes of Pink and, of course, A Fair Forgery of Pink Floyd). Some are not so good (like all of the Out of Phase debacles, Pickin on Pink Floyd, the Reggae Tribute to Pink Floyd, The Other Side of Pink Floyd). What is disappointing is that the bad ones cause people to conclude that "all tribute records suck." It's not true -- I can assure you that Out of Phase can't hold my project's jockstrap and ours costs $20 for two CDs instead of $15 poured down a rat hole (unless you happen to show up to a Which One's Pink show in which case it will cost you $15 or two for $25). Freaking Amazon.com has our record "packaged" with Out of Phase's WYWH

Jintzey Wrote:I wasn't trying to imply that ALL tribute albums are bad. In fact, I have quite a collection of PF tributes that I love. It's just unfortunate that most tribute attempts turn out bad so, as you said, it's not usually assumed that a good one will be good until you've heard it.

FloydianGP Wrote:^ so wait, you produced "A Fair Forgery of Pink Floyd" :O

cool