Poll: Roger water opera good idea or bad idea - what ever you pick its ur pick

moodyblue · 09-25-2005 02:39 PM

I think it is a GREAT IDEA!!!!!

I'll be picking up a copy!!

Possibly Related

PinkThePig · 09-25-2005 03:09 PM

I could understand that Roger Waters is experimenting. Having spent a good bit of his life on a project I can see why it came out. It's really a matter of a opinion really but maybe I could change my mind once I hear it. Atom Heart Mother was a good composition but that's just Atom Heart Mother though.

~~pointmeatthesky~~ · 09-25-2005 03:38 PM

BusStopRatBag Wrote:Does this 25$ version come with the DVD and the "lavish" 60 page booklet?

there is a book and dvd? i thought it was just a cd. maybe iw will get it now then.

BusStopRatBag · 09-25-2005 04:13 PM

Yeah there are screen shots from the DVD some where...
Cool

hes wearing glasses

~~pointmeatthesky~~ · 09-25-2005 04:16 PM

COOL, now i wants it. I will get it thursday. then i can get 25% off. :)

RogerIsMyHomeboy · 09-25-2005 07:11 PM

I like how he is expanding his musical horizons so to speak, but opera just is not my thing. So, I think it is good for him, but not so great for his fans who aren't really into this style of music.

~~Pato~~ · 09-26-2005 07:13 AM

Good idea.

snowy white · 12-16-2005 10:19 AM

i think its gonna be awsome

Seamus the Dog · 12-17-2005 09:45 AM

RogerIsMyHomeboy Wrote:I like how he is expanding his musical horizons so to speak, but opera just is not my thing. So, I think it is good for him, but not so great for his fans who aren't really into this style of music.

This is a question, not a criticism: How many operas have you listened to?

I agree with you that many of his fans will be scared off by the mere mention of the word "opera." I think that's mainly because music education is practically non-existent these days.

Asking people with no, or limited, music education to listen to a symphony or opera and expecting them to comprehend what they are hearing is similar to handing them a book written in Croation and asking them an hour later how they liked the story. At best, they will have recognized the occasional word.

People reject classical/serious/formal music (whatever anyone wants to call it. Personally, I think there are only two kinds of music: Good music and bad music.) because it doesn't "speak to them." It doesn't speak to them because they don't have a clue how to listen.

"We don't need no (music) education ..."

Edited By Seamus the Dog on 1134922488

~~pinkfl0ydth3wall~~ · 01-06-2006 06:22 PM

the dudes old let him do wut he wants and the english version is outstanding as far as opreas in english are the melody and voices are just right if not perfect. only thing was... comeon it took him a decade...... but still very cool

Poll: Roger water opera good idea or bad idea - what ever you pick its ur pick
	great idea
	good idea
	ok idea i can understand hes experimenting
	wtf was he thinking idea

Possibly Related Threads...
Thread:		Author	Replies:	Views:	Last Post
	Water's Equipment [Request]	Joe	44	1,971	12-05-2010 08:31 PM Last Post: Floydy
	Roger Waters Show in Atlanta, GA - Anyone know where I can find good pics?	Evander	3	750	08-05-2007 10:54 AM Last Post: lilly4884
	Roger in Oakland - looking for good tickets	See Saw 4	0	184	05-17-2007 10:08 AM Last Post: See Saw 4
	Roger Water June 7 Montreal - Tickets for sale at cost	petey6	0	455	05-15-2007 04:47 PM Last Post: petey6
	2 Tickets And Passes To Meet Roger Water	charityfolks	0	592	05-11-2007 06:24 AM Last Post: charityfolks

Threaded Mode \| Linear Mode Roger water opera good idea or bad idea - what ever you pick its ur pick
Author	Message