I feel Nick would be glad to have Roger back. I don't think Rick and Roger ever got along. Dave had some pretty harsh things to say about Roger in the lyrics of Division Bell. I believe Dave feels that Pink Floyd without Roger is still a successful Pink Floyd (especially financially).

Besides, I read a rumor that Dave claims Pink Floyd is over. He feels he doesn't have the energy or the voice range anymore. Of course it is just a rumor.

How about a Pink Floyd with Roger replacing Dave??? ???



Edited By scarlet eagle on 1062980886

I don't think Mr. Gilmour has ever decided PF's fate, from what I've read.

At this time, my greatest hope is on solo albums, which I very much hope to see from Rick Wright, Roger Waters, and David Gilmour. That would be very nice. :)

I was gonna say I'll check this out until I realised it's about 7 months old.

This is really, really old isn't it? Almost a whole YEAR old... Roger looks... different. He's still pretty though... :)

I think if they'll reunite again it's good by the way and I hope for see'em live here in Barcelona,let's hope for the reunion it's real because I've never seen'em live so for Gilmour,Waters,Wright,Mason and the collaboration of Barret in writing the new stuff for the new album.
Monty

(09-07-2003 04:27 PM)scarlet eagle Wrote:  [color=#000000] Dave had some pretty harsh things to say about Roger in the lyrics of Division Bell.

Could you quote some of those for me? I'm interested, but not enough to hunt them down myself.

(12-14-2009 08:31 AM)setthecontrols09 Wrote:  Could you quote some of those for me? I'm interested, but not enough to hunt them down myself.

All you have to do is Google "Division Bell lyrics". Or better yet, Google the lyrics to Poles Apart and Lost For Words.

Of course this is a six year old thread referring to a far different issue of Mojo. You could also just go to the front page here in the lyrics section.

I don't foresee that dichotomy of chemistry ever coming together again. Two alpha musicians who may never come together again. I would be pleasantly surprised if I was wrong.

they did once for Live 8. bam. reuinion. THANK YOU! WELCOME! GOOD EVENING!