Threaded Mode | Linear Mode

floydianyid · 07-22-2004 08:11 AM

sort of the best 20

1.Set the Controls for the Heart of the Sun
2.Echoes
3.The Gnome
4.Time
5.Dogs
6.Hey You
7.Speak To Me/Breathe
8.Us And Them
9.Arnold Layne
10.Eclipse
11.Julia Dream
12.Brain Damage
13.The Thin Ice
14.Comfortably Numb
15.The Scarecrow
16. Welcome to the Machine
17.See Emily Play
18.Wish You Were Here
19.Shine On You Crazy Diamond
20.Alan's Psychedelic Breakfast

Possibly Related

paxs · 07-22-2004 09:16 AM

PFOnline Wrote:

Your Top 20 Pink Floyd Songs - Vote now

Q and MOJO Magazines will soon be releasing a special edition version of there magazine featuring Pink Floyd. They have contacted us and requested we post the following:

Dear Pink Floyd Fan,
Q and MOJO magazines need your vote. Please let us know your personal 20 Best Pink Floyd Songs Of All Time for publication in an upcoming special edition completely devoted to Pink Floyd. Please e-mail your entries to special.projects@emap.com, and watch this space for more details.

Best 20 PINK FLOYD songs ever

Comfortably numb
Another brick in the wall (part 2)
Keep Talking
the final cut
On the turning away
Shine on you crazy diamond
Marooned
Us and them
One of my turns
Breath
The great gig in the sky
Time
Goodbye blue sky
Dogs
The Fletchers memorial home
Yet another movie
Wish you were here
Young lust
Southampton dock
Hey You

**PFOnline** · 07-22-2004 02:52 PM

I'm not sure if they will count the Top 20's posted here... If you want to be sure your list gets counted, make sure you email in your list to special.projects@emap.com ... :)

Cheers
PFOnline

floydianyid · 07-23-2004 02:02 AM

PFOnline Wrote:I'm not sure if they will count the Top 20's posted here... If you want to be sure your list gets counted, make sure you email in your list to special.projects@emap.com ... :)

Cheers
PFOnline

i did email it to them i just thought i'd copy and paste the email and post it here aswell

quevez · 07-23-2004 03:24 AM

It is rather irrational to vote on 20 `best` Floyd`s songs !
Every supporter of the band knows the answer...it is a group which cannot be valued by only some of the projects.Every song has something different to say as all of them were made in different conditions...and so far and so long!
I laugh at the fact that someone gives a list of Floyd`s 20 most popular or best (or whatever) songs in history.
I`ll tell You what...I`ll vote on Pink Floyd as the fantastic group of rock music of all times not on some of the songs.
greetings

DAWN!Z · 07-23-2004 04:22 AM

floydianyid Wrote:
PFOnline Wrote:I'm not sure if they will count the Top 20's posted here... If you want to be sure your list gets counted, make sure you email in your list to special.projects@emap.com ... :)

Cheers
PFOnline
i did email it to them i just thought i'd copy and paste the email and post it here aswell

me too!
Cheers!
Dennis

DAWN!Z · 07-23-2004 04:24 AM

quevez Wrote:It is rather irrational to vote on 20 `best` Floyd`s songs !
Every supporter of the band knows the answer...it is a group which cannot be valued by only some of the projects.Every song has something different to say as all of them were made in different conditions...and so far and so long!
I laugh at the fact that someone gives a list of Floyd`s 20 most popular or best (or whatever) songs in history.
I`ll tell You what...I`ll vote on Pink Floyd as the fantastic group of rock music of all times not on some of the songs.
greetings

You are absolutely right.
But hey, they asked, so I did it....

Cheers
Dawn!Z-Rawk-awn!z

Dyolf · 07-23-2004 04:44 AM

Mine are:

1. Astronomy Domine
2. Learning To Fly
3. Sorrow
4. On The Turning Away
5. Take It Back
6. High Hopes
7. One Of These Days
8. Time
9. Money
10. Us & Them
11. Any Colour You Like
12. Shine On You Crazy Diamond (all)
13. Wish You Were Here
14. Comfortably Numb
15. Another Brick In The Wall (Part 2)
16. Echoes
17. Hey You
18. Careful With That Axe, Eugene
19. Run Like Hell (live)
20. The Fletcher Memorial Home

07-23-2004 05:04 AM

Great fun though it may be to list ones 20 best floyd songs (though rather Aristotlian), does nobody else think that the whole Q/Mojo thing is a load of nonsense?

batundeira · 07-23-2004 08:57 AM

Hi, here are muy favourites:

1.- Shine on your Crazy Diamons (all parts)
2.- Comfortably Numb
3.- Wish Yoy Were Here
4.- Time
5.- Echoes
6.- Another Brick on The Wall part 2
7.- On The Turning Away
8.- High Popes
9.- Money
10- Athom Heart Mother
12.- Sheeps
13.- Hey You
14.- Young Lust
15.- In the Flesh
16.- Interestellar Overdrive
17.- See Emily Play
18.- Brain Damage
19.- A Saccefull of Secrets
20- Eclipse

Greetings from a spanish Floyd fan.

hammers

Threaded Mode \| Linear Mode Your Top 20 Pink Floyd Songs - Vote now
Author	Message