Very good post, Jeff. Neither of them need the money, as was proved when they turned down the multi-million tour in the wake of Live 8. I just don't know what they would think to be a reasonable cause, though, if the deaths of two of their original members doesn't spark them into action . . .

Doing a dedication concert would be beautiful. I think they should do something like this.
D from bklyn

I don't know if appealing to their sentimental side will even get noticed . The one that would really have to make the leap would be David anyway and I do not think he is any shape to be making that big of a leap . It is true that those closest to us have the ability to really frak us up the most . If I were him , I don't know if I would be willing to volunteer for all the pain , real or imagined , that he may associate with working with Roger . Personally , I would love to see it , again , but I am also alright with what I got at Live 8 . In the end the only opinion that matters is the boys in the band , if they aren't on board , all of them , then it won't happen .

With Rick gone? i love Floyd, and have seen them a few times. Its over, and I love Floyd. Its over. Enjoy what we have left to sift through.

Sorry people, but for me sounds the idea of a Rick-Wright-Pink-Floyd-memorial-concert very cynic. After all the stuff that happend between Rick and Roger, why should ROGER WATERS appear on a tribute concert for Rick. Remember he has not only pushed Rick out of the band but if we believe what David Gilmour and Bob Enzrin said about this time than he had treated Rick like the dirt under his fingernails.
Sorry again, but when people say they want "a Pink Floyd reunion for Rick" when they in fact mean they want a Pink Floyd reunion for themself than I feel
I would love a Rick Wright tribute by Gilmour and Mason together with some people who feel influenced by Rick but in my humble opinion Roger Waters should stay away from it.
I remember very well the Syd Barrett tribute were everybody else played a song written by Syd only Roger decided to use one of his solo-songs...typical would I say. Seems that he is not even in such situation able to give someone else a little bit acknowledgement for their work.

Well you know what the say about opinions .

Jeff 2008 Wrote:Well you know what the say about opinions .

Very true...but not only for me but for the "we deserve a reunion" people, too

Kirara2001 , that is eveyone , including me .

Are we mature or not? he said that's over if it is over than so it be.But don't judge him.You are not God on earth.You can not judge someone's decision.Pink Floyd is his child, as well as Roger's, Nick's, Rick's and of course Syd's.I do wish so much to see them for the very first time in my life.I'm listening for 17 years old Pink Floyd now I'm 22.My first album which i had listened to was amused to death of 5 years old.About this album my father says that:"is good to have it in your house".Every time when he was returning from his voyage he was learning me a lot of things.One of them, Pink Floyd.But anyhow, do not judge someone's work or decision concerning his wishes about his future and own life, is common-sense.