Poll: In Favor of 'Dogs', which would go? - man..talk about playing Devil's advocate

whong · 03-27-2006 03:45 PM

well...this is going to get a bit heated, I'd say.....

Due to time restrictions during Dave's tour right now, one of these would have to be nixed, in favor of 'Dogs' being added to the setlist.

Edited By whong on 1143503424

Possibly Related

ha_ha_charade_you_are · 03-27-2006 04:00 PM

Well, my two favorite Floyd songs are dogs and Echoes and Shine on isn't even in my top 10, so get rid of Shine On I say.

If it were to mean that he would get rid of Echoes, then I wouldn't want him to play it. I really want to see Echoes live. I saw Roger play Dogs 9 times, and have never seen Echoes live.

~~pointmeatthesky~~ · 03-27-2006 04:14 PM

Shine On, we've ALL heard it before.

Echoes is far more interesting!

OutsideTheWall · 03-27-2006 04:26 PM

If I had to pick one of those it would be shine on, but why remove either? How about removing two other songs such as Dominoes and Fat old sun, or Wearing the inside out or etc?

ha_ha_charade_you_are · 03-27-2006 04:32 PM

Yeah, he could take out Dominoes, Wearing The Inside Out, and Wots, Uh The Deal......not High Hopes though....I like that tune a lot.

whong · 03-27-2006 04:36 PM

C'mon guys...stay with the poll here....those shorter songs are not going anywhere, except for a bit of rotation, show to show....

whong · 03-27-2006 04:54 PM

actually...what the hell....I guess we could come up with an ultimate Floyd section for this show, couldn't we? This is almost too easy...

Echoes
All of OAI

break

Shine On, first half
Childhood's End
Murder
Breakthrough
On The Turning Away
Dogs
High Hopes
Shine On, second half
Instrumental Floyd medley, combining riffs from Young Lust, Run Like Hell, Cymbaline, and winding down with the full performance of Marooned.(I think this would work out)

Encore of WYWH, Dark Side Medley, Comfortably Numb

I've totally blown the hell out of my "time restrictions" thing, haven't I?

Edited By whong on 1143507367

floydianyid · 03-27-2006 04:57 PM

no way keep both those songs, dogs is good but not that good.

Edited By floydianyid on 1143507472

mabewa · 03-27-2006 06:01 PM

I voted for Shine On. Classic song, but Floyd, Dave and Roger have played it plenty. Dave has never played Dogs to my knowledge, nor did the post-Waters Floyd. And Echoes... just hasn't been played enough by anyone in the past 20 plus years. It needs to stay.

FixedRate · 03-28-2006 03:22 AM

I would love him to drop Shine On for Dogs......

Echoes was fantastic by the way in Amsterdam....
rocker

Possibly Related Threads...
Thread:		Author	Replies:	Views:	Last Post
	Thing ive learnt about davids playing	pinkfloydfan1	4	1,215	12-17-2008 11:10 PM Last Post: "Capt. Midnight"
	gilmour playing Us and Them - classic albums DSOTM	atom heart mother suit	9	1,351	11-05-2007 11:44 AM Last Post: PlanetJeff
	Dave playing bass with Spinal Tap... - weird video I found on YouTube.	FelicityKendall'sUnderwear	2	624	11-07-2006 09:14 AM Last Post: Dyolf
	Gilmour playing in Poland - Gdansk - Hyppocrite	quickpost	7	474	05-24-2006 06:12 AM Last Post: Mike Bull
	Gilmour playing Purple Rain	RADAR_Brian	5	519	05-22-2006 09:58 PM Last Post: Sadie

Poll: In Favor of 'Dogs', which would go? - man..talk about playing Devil's advocate
	Shine On You Crazy Diamond
	Echoes

Threaded Mode \| Linear Mode In Favor of 'Dogs', which would go? - man..talk about playing Devil's advocate
Author	Message