If you watch Pompeii, Mademoiselle Nobs, you'll see that Dave is playing the harmonica, Roger is playing Daves "Black Strat", Rick is holding the mic for Nobs and Nick isn't there. So who's playing bass? There's definately bass there, I can hear it on my audio rip.

Yeah, I noticed this myself. My friend Alex and I were talking about it. The bass had to be overdubbed later on, but by whom, I'm unsure.

Probably overdubbed by Roger or David later on. Or my Mademoiselle Nobs herself. :sleepy:

The overdubbing and the French studio shots let Pompeii down IMO, but I still love it

The alternate setting in the French studio makes the film even more expansive and interesting to me. Do you know what my favorite bit from the French footage is? When Rick Wright runs his fingers up and down the keyboard during is solo in the bridge of "Set The Controls For The Heart Of The Sun". I love the camera work.

David is good on the harmonica.

(07-16-2007 02:34 AM)Dyolf Wrote:  If you watch Pompeii, Mademoiselle Nobs, you'll see that Dave is playing the harmonica, Roger is playing Daves "Black Strat", Rick is holding the mic for Nobs and Nick isn't there. So who's playing bass? There's definately bass there, I can hear it on my audio rip.

Your Right!! I just watched it and there is a bass sound in there!
I have no idea where it came from, I still love watching,,,any reason I can get!!!
Thank-you.. Luv Nobz...

---

(07-17-2007 05:39 PM)William Gerrard Wrote:  The alternate setting in the French studio makes the film even more expansive and interesting to me. Do you know what my favorite bit from the French footage is? When Rick Wright runs his fingers up and down the keyboard during is solo in the bridge of "Set The Controls For The Heart Of The Sun". I love the camera work.

I must agree..
My heart stay pounding

Actually I think it was overdubbed by Roger. Dave's style is different than what's played in that song.